Skip to main content

Status reports, BI dashboards, PPM tools and verified status compared

Leaders get portfolio status from one of four kinds of source, often several at once. Each answers a different question. This guide compares them plainly, so you can see which gaps you have and which you do not.

By the Tarivra team · · 6 min read

Status reports

A program manager writes a status, usually Green, Amber or Red, with a few lines of commentary, weekly or monthly.

  • Good at: context and judgment that only people have, such as a vendor risk or a key person leaving.
  • Falls short: it is self-reported, lags the work, and drifts optimistic until a problem is certain.
  • Best used for: the narrative, alongside evidence.

BI dashboards

Data from tools such as Jira or Azure DevOps is modeled in a BI tool and shown as charts.

  • Good at: flexible analysis, and combining delivery data with finance or HR data.
  • Falls short: someone has to build and maintain the model, charts need interpretation, and a dashboard rarely says whether the reported status is right.
  • Best used for: analysts and PMO teams exploring trends.

PPM tools

Project and portfolio management tools hold plans, budgets, resources and approvals for the portfolio.

  • Good at: planning, funding, capacity and the approval process for what gets done.
  • Falls short: status inside them is usually entered by hand, and the engineering work often lives in other tools.
  • Best used for: deciding what to fund and tracking spend.

Verified status

Software reads the work in the tools teams use and checks each reported status against it, citing the evidence.

  • Good at: showing early which Green programs are not Green, the same way across every tool, with the records behind each statement.
  • Falls short: it does not plan or fund work, and it needs the work to be in a tool it can read.
  • Best used for: executives and PMO leads who need to trust the status they act on, and to follow decisions through.

How they fit together

  • PPM decides what to do and funds it.
  • Teams do the work in Jira, Azure DevOps, ServiceNow, GitHub or GitLab.
  • Status reports carry the human context.
  • Verified status checks the reports against the work and tracks decisions to done.
  • BI explores whatever else the business wants to analyze.

The gap most organizations have is the fourth: nothing checks the status report against the work before it reaches executives.

Where Tarivra fits

Tarivra is verified status, which we call Verified Program Intelligence. It works alongside a PPM tool and BI, reading the work in Jira, Azure DevOps, ServiceNow, GitHub and GitLab and checking each program's reported status against it.

Questions

Do I need a PPM tool and verified status?

They do different jobs. PPM plans and funds work; verified status checks whether the reported status of that work is true. Many organizations use both.

Can a BI dashboard do what verified status does?

Partly, with enough modeling. The hard parts are applying the same checks to every program in every tool, citing the evidence, and keeping it current every week.

Which should we fix first?

If programs keep turning Red late, start with checking reported status against the work. It is the cheapest gap to close and the one that changes decisions soonest.